Phone answered 24/7 · Louisville, KY and nearby communities

Call 24/7: (502) 305-4876
Beargrass Creek Water ResponseWater Damage Help · Louisville, KY

Why Does a Blue Tarp on a Roof Eventually Allow More Water In?

Last updated October 31, 2026

The short answer

How a Tarp Fails

A tarp is stretched over a damaged roof and secured with nails or ropes. That setup works for a day or two. But the sun breaks down the plastic, making it brittle. Wind works the fasteners loose. The tarp starts to flutter, and each flap pulls the edges away from the roof surface.

Water finds those gaps. Once the tarp lifts in one corner, rain runs underneath instead of over the top. The original leak now has two entry points: the old hole and the new gap. The tarp also holds moisture against the roof deck, which can speed up rot and rust.

Why Pooling Water Makes It Worse

A flat or low-slope roof can let water collect in the middle of the tarp. That pooled water is heavy. It stretches the tarp, pulls the fasteners, and can tear the material. The weight also presses down on the damaged area, which may push water through small cracks in the roof deck.

Once a tarp tears, the tear can grow quickly. A small rip becomes a long slit as the wind catches it. The original repair spot is now a larger opening than before. The tarp is no longer a barrier; it is a funnel.

  • Wind lifts the tarp edges and loosens nails
  • UV rays make the plastic brittle and cracked
  • Pooled water adds weight and stress
  • Tears grow from small rips to long slits
  • Fasteners rust or pull out of the roof
  • The tarp shifts, exposing the original hole

What a Tarp Is For

A tarp is meant to buy a little time, not to be a permanent roof. It can slow down water entry for a few days while you arrange for a real repair. But the longer it stays, the more it becomes a problem itself. The roof underneath is still damaged and still leaking.

The pros use tarps as a stopgap measure, not a solution. They also inspect what is underneath and plan the actual repair. If you have a tarp on your roof, treat it as a temporary bandage and push for a permanent fix soon.

When a Tarp Is Not Enough

If the roof has structural damage, such as a sagging deck or broken rafters, a tarp will not hold. The weight of water or snow can collapse the whole thing. A tarp also does nothing for water that has already soaked into insulation, drywall, or wood framing. That water spreads and causes mold.

You need a plan that includes removing soaked materials and drying the structure. The pros can assess the damage and recommend the next step. In the meantime, keep the tarp as secure as possible, but know its limits.

What to Do Next

Inspect the tarp after every storm. Look for lifted edges, tears, and pooling water. If you can, remove the pooled water with a broom or a mop. Re-secure any loose fasteners. But remember, this is a temporary fix. The real repair is a new roof or a patch that is sealed and flashed properly.

If you live in Louisville, you may want to write down the name of a local roofing contractor. But for immediate help, consider a water damage inspection to see what is happening inside your walls and ceiling. The sooner you address the source, the less damage you will have.

  • Check the tarp after heavy rain or wind
  • Remove any pooled water with a broom
  • Re-secure loose nails or ropes
  • Look for tears and patch them with tape
  • Schedule a permanent roof repair
  • Have a water damage inspection if water got inside

Need help right now?

Call (502) 305-4876 any time, day or night, and describe what happened.

Call Now (502) 305-4876

Frequently asked questions

How long can a blue tarp stay on a roof?

A tarp is only a short-term fix, usually a few days to a couple of weeks. The longer it stays, the more it degrades. Wind and sun will cause it to fail. Plan for a permanent repair as soon as possible.

Can I put a second tarp over the first one?

You can, but it is not a long-term solution. A second tarp adds weight and can hold water between the layers. It may buy a little time, but it does not fix the underlying damage. Get a proper repair done.

What should I do if water is already coming in?

Move furniture and valuables away from the leak. Place buckets to catch drips. Dry the area as much as you can to prevent mold. Then contact a water damage pro to inspect and dry the affected areas. The tarp will not stop water that is already inside.

Call Now (502) 305-4876